I can’t actually remember the last time I purchased a candy bar. But if you toss some notable candy bar pieces into ice cream, I’m only too happy to devour them with alacrity. Such was the case with Everything But The …, which features my favorite Ben & Jerry’s mix-in: the peanut butter cup. In addition to peanut butter cups, this pint included faux Heath Bar pieces, chocolate-covered almonds and medicinal white chocolate chunks. If you can navigate around the latter, which vulgarized an otherwise sensible grouping of mix-ins, you’ve got an enjoyable pint on your hands.
Pr(Buy Again): High