Four Days in New York (August Edition)

While I noshed each day, the focus of this post will be on my sit-down meals, starting with my hands-down favorite restaurant in the country: Eleven Madison Park.

After tending to some political science business in DC, I hopped on the Amtrak, arriving at Penn Station just before noon, giving me just enough time to check into my hotel before ambling over to the Flatiron to meet raconteur par excellence, The Wizard of Roz, and her husband, The Oenophilist.

What ensued was a four-hour cavalcade of spectacular courses. While animal protein is handled deftly—most notably in the Homage to the Jewish Deli and in the slightly messy but ever so enjoyable lobster boil—it was the vegetables that bowled me over. A two-part tomato course began with a vibrant tomato tea infused with lemon verbena, a dish that hasn’t been on the menu since the 2012 summer, followed by a bowl of Tri-star strawberries, variegated tomatoes, micro basil and stipples of olive oil.

But the biggest surprise came from the restaurant’s riff on artichokes en barigoule. In lieu of artichoke the kitchen used sunflower. Topped with a brioche crust, the disc of sunflower packed an umami punch, tempered by a sharp watercress purée. And it should go without saying, but service is as cloudless as ever, making guests feel as if they are the only table in the grand palazzo of a dining room.


Day 2 featured Round 2 at EMP this time with a full embrace of vegetables. The final three savory courses would prove to be a contest of sensations, beginning with a palate-caressing peach purée atop a preternaturally sweet peach that married unbelievably well with celtuce and trout roe. Next, an almost custard-like roasted eggplant balanced with a crunchy ribbon of pickled eggplant all amid a scattering of fried quinoa. And for the main course, a puck of aioli-topped pumpernickel lay at the center of the plate festooned by slow-cooked summer beans.

And though my sweet tooth has dampened over the years, the brownie sundae finished tableside with rum caramel includes an ethereal set of textures: chewy cubes of brownie, creamy vanilla ice cream, crisp waffle cone pieces and the gossamer-thin dark chocolate edifice that houses the sundae. 







On my third visit to NoMad this year, I definitely overindulged. That said, all eight dishes I tried were delicious.The kitchen would start by sending out their take on fruits de mer, which included, inter alia, a scallop tartare spiked with jalapeno, creamy sea urchin panna cotta and a king crab custard of which I could effortlessly eat spoonfuls. Given the wide selection of the menu I sampled, it seems hard to go wrong; particularly notable were the salad of plump grapes and diaphanous slices of fennel atop a tangy yogurt, eggplant five ways with an inimitable Bourbon barrel-aged fish sauce and what can only be described as a pond of velvet: a perfectly poached egg, melting slivers of parmesan and brown butter espuma, all enhanced by nutty quinoa and bite-size pieces of tender asparagus. 





And I wrapped up my trip with a visit to Carbone, Rich Torrisi and Mario Carbone’s temple to red sauce Italian-American restaurants. To say portions are on the large side is tantamount to saying ISIS doesn’t conduce to world peace. This is hibernation food.

Because it was pushing 90 degrees outside on the day of my reservation, I started with the relatively light Caesar salad; the crisp romaine did indeed prove to be refreshing, and the croutons were unlike any I’ve ever had. And the veal parm is simply stunning, a veritable land mass interspersed with crisp edges and mountainous sections boasting a thick mozzarella carapace. It’s large enough to keep a team of geologists occupied for weeks.

This is definitely a restaurant to which I’d return, for in addition to the delicious food, charming staff and a lively dining room—the restaurant was nearly full by 6pm—made for a great first visit. 



Below are links to all of the photos from the aforementioned meals:

EMP Regular Menu

EMP Vegetable Menu 




2 thoughts on “Four Days in New York (August Edition)

  1. I publish the OAD Top 100 US Restaurant List

    The list is based on a survey of experienced diners. You can see the list of the top 100 reviewers here:

    I found your blog while doing a search for Saison and given the restaurants you have visited, it looks like you would be able to make an important contribution.

    If you are interested in participating and you have the time to fill out the survey, you can register at the link below. The pre-certification code is the word olive. The way the survey works, the more quality restaurants you review, the more your vote impacts the results.

    If you prefer you can put your reviews on an Excel spreadsheet and I can have our IT department upload them to the database. If you would like to do it via spreadsheet, please let me know and I will send you additional information about what fields are needed on the spreadsheet.

    In addition to reviewing US restaurants, you can also review restaurants in Europe, Asia and Central & South American.

    Thanks for your time. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to email me.

    Steve P.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s